John 8:46-59
Pastor James Preus
Trinity Lutheran Church
March 17, 2024
Our Gospel lesson today is a portion of one of the most contentious arguments Jesus ever had with the Jewish leaders. They call Him a Samaritan and say that He has a demon, while they claim to be Abraham’s children and that God is their Father. Jesus claims God Himself as His Father and that He is Abraham’s friend, while He calls them children of their father the devil! A conversation cannot get much more heated than that! Yet, both Jesus and His opponents claim Moses, Abraham, and God to be on their side! They both claim the Holy Scriptures written by Moses and the Prophets, Abraham, of whom Moses wrote, and God, who they say caused Holy Scripture to be written. How is it then that they are so diametrically opposed to each other, that they claim the other to be on Satan’s side?
It has to do with the proper distinction between the Law and the Gospel. There are two main teachings in Scripture: the Law and the Gospel. The Law is what God commands of you. The Gospel is what God does for you through Christ. The Law demands works. The Gospel is a free gift. The Law condemns the lawbreaker to death and hell. The Gospel offers forgiveness and eternal life to the lawbreaker, who believes in Christ. These Jews believed that the Holy Scriptures were only Law, that is, that they were only commandments for them to do. And they thought that they inherited eternal life by doing the commandments! They did not recognize that the main teaching of the Holy Scriptures is that God would send the Christ to take away sin and grant eternal life to all who believe in Him.
Jesus says to the Jews earlier in John chapter 5, “You search the Scriptures, because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness of Me, yet you refuse to come to Me that you may have life.” (John 5:39-40) and a little later He says, “There is one who accuses you: Moses, on whom you have set your hope. For if you believed Moses, you would believe Me; for he wrote of Me.” (John 5:45-46) This does not mean that Christ rejects the commandments of the Law. Jesus said, “I did not come to abolish the Law and the Prophets, but to fulfill them.” (Matthew 5:17) And Jesus warns, “Everyone who commits sin is a slave to sin.” (John 8:34) Jesus came to earth as an enemy of sin. He comes to rescue us from our sins. He does not abolish the commandments of God, but he puts them in their proper place. The commandments indeed hem us in and enclose us under condemnation, so that Christ may come and liberate us by grace (Romans 11:32; Galatians 3:22).
The Old Testament is not just a list of commandments. And if you think that all the Bible is, is a bunch of commandments, then you will inevitably add your own rules in an attempt to make God’s commandments more doable. That’s what legalists do. They add their own rules to God’s Law, so that they can convince themselves that they are fulfilling God’s Law by obeying their own rules. Yet, man’s commandments do not liberate you from God’s Law. Rather, they further enslave you to sin! This is why Jesus speaks so harshly to these legalists. They claim to listen to Moses and to be children of Abraham, but they do not listen to Moses or behave like Abraham’s children.
At the time of this argument, the Jews were celebrating the Feast of Booths or the Festival of Tabernacles (John 7:2). Every fall for seven days the children of Israel would live in tents, while offering special sacrifices to the Lord. They did this, so that they would remember that they had lived in temporary shelters in the wilderness when God brought them out of the Land of Egypt, as Moses writes in Leviticus 23 (:33-43). Yet, this is not the only reason to observe this festival. When Israel was dwelling in tents in the wilderness, Moses constructed the Tabernacle, a large tent where God Himself dwelt. So, when the people of Israel celebrated the Festival of Tabernacles by living in tents for seven days, they also remembered that at that time God began to dwell with His people in the Tabernacle. The Tabernacle foreshadows Christ, God’s own Son, who would come to dwell with His people in human flesh and walk among them.
Jesus is the fulfillment of that Tabernacle. He is the Word made flesh, which tabernacled among the people of Israel (John 1:14). This is why Jesus told them, “Before Abraham was, I AM.” Just as God existed before He dwelt in the Tabernacle in the wilderness, so He existed before He dwelt in human flesh as Jesus Christ. But now, the greater Tabernacle is here, the great promise of all Scripture, Christ, our God dwelling with us in human flesh! Yet, these poor students of Moses do not recognize it.
Moses wrote of Abraham, whose children they claimed to be. “If you were Abraham’s children, you would be doing the works Abraham did,” Jesus told them. Abraham lived before Scripture was written, but God spoke to him directly. It was Christ, the Word of God, who spoke to Abraham and told Him to sacrifice his only beloved son Isaac. Isaac was not only Abraham’s son by blood, but through faith in the promise. Although he was in the vigor of youth and could have overpowered his elderly father, he willingly carried the wood of the offering up the mountain, permitted his father to bind him and lay him upon the wood, and waited patiently as a lamb to the slaughter as his father reached for his knife. It was Christ, the Angel of the LORD, who is the LORD, who called out to Abraham to do no harm to his son. He then provided Abraham a ram to sacrifice in place of his son. Isaac and that ram are types, which prefigure Christ Jesus, God’s beloved only begotten Son, who willingly bore the wood of His cross and was sacrificed on it for our sins. God did as Abraham prophesied, and provided a Lamb on the mount of the LORD. And Christ did what He told Abraham He would do, by blessing all nations of the earth in his offspring.
This is how Abraham was able to rejoice to see Jesus’ day. He saw Jesus’ day through faith in the promised Christ, who is before him from eternity. The Jews were offended that Jesus, clearly not yet fifty years old by His human nature, claimed to know Abraham, who had died eighteen centuries earlier. Yet, even in this claim they showed their ignorance of Abraham’s faith. God is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. God is not the God of the dead, but of the living (Matthew 22:32). This is what Abraham and Isaac trusted as they climbed the mount of the LORD. Hebrews 11 states, “By faith Abraham, when he was tested, offered up Isaac, and he who had received the promise was in the act of offering up his only son, of whom it was said, ‘through Isaac should your offspring be named.’ He considered that God was able even to raise the dead, from which, figuratively speaking, he did receive him back.” (Hebrews 11:17-19) Abraham believed in the resurrection of Christ and the resurrection of all flesh before Scripture had even been written. And all of Scripture is written to proclaim this faith of Abraham.
This message of grace, forgiveness, and eternal life through Christ infuriated the Jewish leaders, who claimed Moses, Abraham, and God on their side. And so, it always is for those who reject Christ’s Word. Those who reject Christ’s Word hate Christ. And as the treatment of Christ’s prophets and apostles attests, they also hate those who openly confess Christ’s Word. Jesus told them, “Whoever is of God hears the words of God. The reason why you do not hear them is that you are not of God.” Those who do not listen to God’s Word, particularly, those who ignore God’s message of forgiveness and salvation through the work of Christ Jesus will hate Christ and his Christians and will try to silence the preaching of the Gospel.
Jesus preached both the Law and the Gospel. He told sinners to repent and warned against lust, hatred, greed, and hypocrisy. Yet, He was willing to forgive even the most loathsome sinner. By His preaching, He brought the greatest outcasts and those in the deepest pit of sin and despair back into Christ’s fold, so that even the Gentiles glorified the God of Israel. Jesus faithfully taught every dot and tittle of Scripture, leaving no word out, so that He could not be accurately accused of abandoning Moses or any of the Scriptures. Rather, He opened the eyes of the lost, so that they could clearly perceive the teaching of God. And for all this, these legalists hated Him and accused Him of having a demon.
This is what becomes of rejecting Christ’s Word and ignoring the message of Scripture: hatred, unbelief, and slavery to sin. But those who hear Christ’s Word and hold fast to it never taste death. Rather, they live forever. The same thing that infuriates Jesus’ opponents gives us the greatest joy and comfort. “Truly, truly, I say to you, if anyone keeps my word, he will never see death.” How can Christ offer eternal life to all who believe in Him? Because before Abraham was, Christ is. Christ is the eternal God, who spoke to Abraham, promising to bless the world through his offspring, who spoke to Moses in the burning bush and at the Tent of Meeting, promising to come and dwell with His people as their brother. And it is this Christ, who offers Himself as a sacrifice more pure and holy than Isaac, to pay for that which that ram and every other bloody offering of sheep and cattle could never pay.
God’s own blood was shed on the cross for us. Christ our God died to pay the debt incurred by our sin (Romans 6:23). This means that no sin, however great or many, can surpass the price Christ paid to make atonement for us. Death comes through sin. Christ bore all sins in His body on the tree. So, yes. Christ can promise eternal life to all who believe in Him, and He can give it as well.
The Jews were right to search the Scriptures to find eternal life. But their searching was in vain, because they would not listen to God’s promise of grace through Christ. But Abraham, Moses, and all of Scripture bear witness of Christ Jesus. Christ Jesus gives eternal life to all who believe in Him. Let us rejoice with Abraham to know this, so that we too will never see eternal death. Amen.